A successful transformation can win awards. A poor one can spawn thousands of analytical articles. Here are 19 actors who transformed their characters so completely that the backlash against their roles became more viral than the film itself:
1. Bradley Cooper's transformation into the Maestro sparked controversy immediately after the trailer's release. Audiences immediately criticized the fake nose Cooper wore while playing the Jewish-American composer and conductor Leonard Bernstein. Critics claimed the choice fueled anti-Semitic stereotypes, particularly because Cooper is not Jewish. Subsequently, awards season discussion of the film shifted from his performance to the question of whether the fake nose was even necessary.
Netflix and Getty
Bernstein's children publicly defended the prosthesis, saying, "It's just a terribly annoying distraction [...] People who were waiting to get angry were just waiting to lash out.".
2. Robert Downey Jr.'s role in Tropic Thunder remains one of the most debated in the context of actor transformation, as he plays a white actor who uses the Stanislavski method, surgically darkening his skin to portray a Black soldier. Defenders claim the joke is on the incompetence of Hollywood actors, while critics say blackface is just blackface.
Getty & DreamWorks Pictures
In an episode of The Joe Rogan Experience podcast, Robert Downey Jr. defends his choice, stating, "90% of my black friends were like, 'Dude, that was great.' I can't disagree with [the rest of the 10%], but I know where my heart belongs.".
3. Ariana Grande's transformation into the Wicked Witch has sparked widespread controversy, with many claiming that Glinda has completely adopted her voice, speech patterns, singing style, wardrobe, skin tone, and general features. Every new music video featuring Grande sparks a discussion in the comments about whether "Glinda has finally let her go.".
Getty
On the topic: The latest episode of Euphoria was even more raunchy than the last—here's a full recap of the most shocking moments.
Right now, everything Grande does is accused of being "stuck in character." One TikTok user even wrote, "Sad. Ariana is stuck in character. Not the same person anymore.".
4. Austin Butler's portrayal of Elvis was widely derided because Elvis's voice seemed to remain unchanged. After three years of intense "method" acting, he continued to speak with a noticeable Elvis-like accent during awards season, leading people to wonder if he'd been stuck in character all these years...
Warner Bros. & Getty
During an appearance on "The Late Show With Stephen Colbert," Butler said he "had a dialect specialist to help me not sound like Elvis." He also admitted he struggled to reconnect with himself after filming Baz Luhrmann's "Elvis.".
5. Brendan Fraser's return to screen in The Whale drew considerable criticism for wearing a fat suit and prosthetics to play Charlie, a 600-pound man. While his performance was praised by some and even earned him an Oscar, critics argued that the film turned obesity into tragedy and spectacle, raising the question of why the role wasn't simply given to a plus-size actor.
A24 and Getty
In response to criticism, Fraser says, "I'm not a small man. And I don't know what criteria I have to meet to play this role. I only know that I had to play it as honestly as possible.".
6. Even before the release of "Barbie," images of Ryan Gosling as Ken were trending… he was criticized by those who thought he was too old, not "Ken" enough, or simply a poor choice for the role. The bleached hair and fake tan further fueled the controversy—until the movie finally let people understand the concept.
Warner Bros. & Getty
One X user questioned Gosling's casting, writing, "Ryan and Margot, especially Ryan, look awfully old for this movie. 46-year-old Ken [...] Why did young Barbie have to play an old doll? I never imagined my Barbies that old.".
7. The film "Back to Black" faced a huge wave of criticism: Amy Winehouse fans criticized the actress's appearance, her voice, and the very idea of a biopic. Especially given that Amy's life, addiction, and death had already been widely covered in the media, many were upset to see Hollywood monetize her suffering by turning it into a dramatized film.
Focus Features & Getty
See also: If you answer 25 questions of this medical test correctly, you're practically a doctor.
A Reddit user criticized the film, writing, "I really, really wanted the new Amy Winehouse movie not to be an offensive Lifetime original, but that's what it is. A complete waste of $30.".
8. Sydney Sweeney's performance as Cassie on Euphoria has sparked heated online debate, with many arguing that the character's behavior and political views reflect Sweeney's real-life public persona. This is especially true after years of controversy surrounding her mother's "Make 60 Great Again" party, her controversial "great jeans/genes" American Eagle ad, and the ongoing debate about her masculine energy. As Cassie's style and language become increasingly "conservative," critics believe Sweeney is simply "playing herself.".
HBO and American Eagle
One X user wrote, "Cassie confirmed she's a Republican. Sydney Sweeney must have been thrilled about that.".
9. Disney's live-action Snow White caused controversy, in part due to its portrayal of the Seven Dwarfs. After Peter Dinklage criticized the reworking of a story based on dwarf stereotypes, Disney changed its approach and replaced the Seven Dwarfs with CGI characters. Soon after, other actors with dwarfism publicly condemned Dinklage and Disney for shortening their already limited roles rather than enhancing them.
Disney Enterprises, Inc. and Getty
In an interview with the Shey Shey Club, Brad Williams, an actor and comedian with dwarfism, expressed his disappointment, saying, "I would have played a dwarf in a live-action Snow White movie, but they cut the dwarfs. Thank you, Dinklage. […] You know, you've put me and my 6-year-old dwarf daughter out of a job.".
10. Lady Gaga's Gucci-inspired makeover came under fire as she described how she spent months in character as Patrizia Reggiani and used an accent off-camera. The controversy surrounding her "Italian" accent was particularly heated, with viewers debating whether she sounded Italian, Russian, kitsch, or all three.
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Pictures Inc. and Getty
One X user commented, "I mean, with that accent, she would have shined in Anora, but not here. It's a Russian accent, not Italian.".
On topic: Only those who regularly watched Disney Channel after school will be able to guess these songs from "High School Musical" from one screenshot.
11. Ana de Armas and the film Blonde faced a boycott immediately after the trailer's release, with people mocking her Marilyn Monroe-like voice and arguing about her accent. The controversy only intensified after the film's release, when it was further criticized as exploitative and even anti-abortion propaganda due to a CGI scene depicting Marilyn's supposed abortions.
Netflix and 20th Century Fox
One Reddit user commented, "Not only does the movie depict two abortions and a miscarriage, but almost every scene surrounding it is about it.".
12. Emilia Perez faced criticism for many reasons, but Selena Gomez's criticism focused in particular on her performance in Spanish. Viewers criticized her accent and delivery, especially after Mexican actor Eugenio Derbez called her performance "unjustified." But the debate quickly expanded beyond Selena, with many viewers criticizing the French film for reducing Mexico to stereotypes. The resurfacing of offensive tweets from Carla Sofia Gascón further exacerbated the film's success at the awards ceremony.
Netflix and Getty
Gomez commented on Derbez's post, in which she criticized her: "I understand your point of view. I'm sorry I did the best I could with the time I had.".
13. It's no surprise that Sebastian Stan's portrayal of a young Donald Trump in The Apprentice sparked controversy, as anyone knows anything Trump-related always sparks heated debate. However, criticism focused not only on how convincing he looked or sounded, but also on concerns about whether the film would humanize Trump, ridicule him, or turn him into a biographical antihero.
Apprentice Productions Ontario Inc., Profile Productions 2 APS, Tailored Films Ltd. and Charlie Rose
I think the film hit a nerve...: "The false and insensitive film about me called 'The Apprentice' (do they even have the right to use that title without permission?) I hope fails," Trump wrote on Truth Social. "It's a cheap, defamatory, and politically disgusting smear campaign released right before the 2024 Presidential Election to try to damage the greatest political movement in the history of our Country: Make America Great Again!"«
14. Jared Leto's transformation as Paolo Gucci in House of Gucci was so radical that people joked he'd been cast as someone else in the film. Between the bald head, prosthetics, accent, and bold acting choices, critics felt his performance looked more like an Italian caricature than Gucci himself.
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Pictures Inc. and Getty
A Reddit user expressed their thoughts this way: "For better or worse, Leto's performance is quite memorable and standout. He may not even be very good in this film (one might even say he's terrible), but I certainly enjoyed it, and I'm not all that mad that he beat out other (much better) contenders, despite the fact that I have little interest in Leto as an actor otherwise.".
15. Lily James' transformation into Pamela Anderson on Pam & Tommy was visually shocking, but the real criticism came from Pamela herself, who disapproved of the series. Because the show dramatized her stolen private videotape and her tumultuous relationship with Tommy Lee, critics felt the actors exploited and romanticized one of the worst periods of her life without her consent.
Hulu and Getty
Anderson says James sent her a handwritten letter "asking if they could talk," to which she promptly declined. The Baywatch star reiterated, "It was already hurtful enough the first time. […] 'Really? People are still profiting off this?'"«
On topic: Sorry, but this time-limited 80s TV show quiz only applies to people born between 1961 and 1979.
16. Michael Jackson has always been a controversial figure, so a biopic (Michael), produced with the active participation of his family, was bound to raise questions. Michael Jackson's nephew, Jaafar Jackson, was clearly the perfect fit for the lead role, both in appearance and dancing skills. But critics were more concerned about whether the film would explore other aspects of Michael's life—including the allegations, his difficult childhood, and his changes in appearance—and wondered whether it would be a transparent biopic or a sugarcoated tribute.
Lionsgate and Getty
One X user wrote: "I need the movie to talk about his rhinoplasty because that nose was done with incredible care.".
17. Emma Stone's performance in "Poor Things" sparked backlash because her character has the body of an adult woman but the developing mind of a child. While many praised the role for its boldness and feminism, others were dissatisfied with the film's sex scenes and wondered whether its version of empowerment crossed into exploitation.
Searchlight Pictures & Getty
Some Reddit users wrote, "There's a line in the movie where Mark Ruffalo says, 'What happened, Bella? You're losing your mojo,' as Bella starts to mature. If that doesn't clearly show how men prey on and prefer young, naive women, I don't know what does." In response, the film's defenders wrote, "It's meant to be uncomfortable, that's the whole point.".
18. Eddie Redmayne's role in The Danish Girl was criticized because he, a cisgender man, plays Lili Elbe, one of the first high-profile women to undergo gender reassignment surgery. This choice was part of a larger debate about how Hollywood rewards cisgender actors for playing transgender characters, while transgender actors already struggle to land roles.
Focus Features & Getty
In an interview, Redmayne admits, "No, I wouldn't do that now. I made that film with the best of intentions, but I think it was a mistake," and acknowledges that "years of cisgender success were built on transgender stories.".
19. Evan Peters' portrayal of Jeffrey Dahmer in Dahmer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story sparked controversy, as many felt the casting of an actor widely known for his online attractiveness made the real-life serial killer too easy to romanticize. Critics argued that the portrayal risked making Dahmer mysterious, fascinating, or even "likable," which was especially abhorrent given that many of his victims were gay men of color. The backlash intensified when the victims' families claimed they were not consulted and felt re-traumatized, leading to the entire story being perceived as exploitative, sexualized, and romanticized.
Netflix and Getty
Critics exclaimed, "Guys, people are literally making seductive videos of Jeffrey Dahmer on TikTok. It's appalling.".
What other actor transformations turned out to be completely unsuccessful? Share your thoughts in the comments or fill out the anonymous form below—your answer could be published in a future BuzzFeed community post!
Your Daily Brain Workout: Most People Won't Finish the Mega-Word Chain This Weekend—Can You?
Also in the TVAndMovies section: No one born after 1990 has seen 35 of these 42 cult classics.
Also in the TVAndMovies section: How well do you know the origin stories of Disney princesses? I'd be very impressed if you scored 20/20.
Read about it on BuzzFeed.com