Phoebe Bridgers is finally back, but only on her own terms. After a series of small, top-secret, impromptu concerts across the country, the indie rock icon just played her biggest solo show in years at Madison Square Garden—under the strict condition that the thousands of fans in New York City put their phones in special cases and throw away all writing utensils upon entering.
More news from Billboard
-
Lizzo is still that "bitch" on 100% on her long-awaited new album: listen to it now!
-
Taylor Swift experiments with country music again in her new song "I Knew It, I Knew You" from the movie "Toy Story 5": listen to it now!
-
RIIZE have released the full tracklist for their second mini-album, II.
These precautions were taken to prevent Bridgers' unreleased material—much of which she performed Thursday night (June 4)—from leaking online ahead of the release of her yet-to-be-announced but much-discussed third solo album. Even allowing journalists into the venue was a significant step, as the media had been denied access to her previous secret acoustic performances in the American South and Midwest for the past several weeks.
But after she was promised that no new song titles or lyrics would be published in the post-concert reports, her team gave the go-ahead Billboard get into the arena so they could see exactly what kind of magic Bridgers was creating after nearly two years out of the public eye and three times that time without releasing a follow-up to her second album. Punisher .
She didn't disappoint. Embarking on a solo career with the experience gained from critical acclaim for her participation in the phenomenal album Boygenius,« The Album» , opening for Taylor Swift in her billion-dollar box office Eras Tour« and winning more awards than any other 2024 Grammy nominee, she effortlessly introduced the crowd to eight unreleased songs from her next project in a minimalist performance, on a tiny stage furnished with a simple sofa, lava lamps, and a small vintage television. She was joined on stage by just two musicians: Christian Lee Hutson on guitar and Nick White on keyboards.
The songs explore themes of love's fading and how love changes its form, themes of solitude yet the desire to reclaim one's place, and the quest for self-improvement, even if she doesn't yet know how. The idea of death has always been conceptually woven into Bridgers' music, but now she seems more interested in exploring her own mortality, whether through the relationships and behaviors that test her or the uncertainty of how she will spend her limited time. Her parents appear as guest stars in the music, and one particularly poignant song addresses her late father directly, detailing the complexities of her relationship with him, which she had previously only hinted at in her songs.
Bridgers also isn't interested in playing for people who don't support a specific cause she's passionate about. Beyond the press, thousands of fans at MSG were able to attend the game by winning seats in a lottery, and those selected were required to donate just $1 to the Freedom from Immigration Bail Fund, which helps people detained and deported under the Trump administration. "I hate those idiots at ICE," Bridgers said, thanking the crowd for their donations and joking that American immigration officials are like "cops squared.".
But overall, this evening—and the entire mini-tour—was an opportunity for Bridgers to reintroduce herself to her most devoted fans ahead of her larger return to the stage later this year. As one front-row audience member put it, as she furiously strummed her guitar during the most intense section of the opening number, "Motion Sickness," and the crowd sang along to every word: "We're back!"«
Below are the best moments from Bridgers' secret show at MSG.
Circle of Trust
After performing some of her most beloved songs from her discography, including "Waiting Room," "Kyoto," and "Moon Song," Bridgers moved into a section dedicated to new material with amusing tactlessness.
It was like, "We're about to play something new, so if any of you figure out how to stick an Apple Watch up your ass to record, please don't post it online.".
Then, holding out her hands to the thousands of people in front of her, whom she couldn't even see from her seat, she added, "I trust you.".
Phoebe goes to the country club
After a series of new songs about emotionally unavailable partners, self-destructive budding romance, and her father, each anchored by folksy, haunting melodies—which may have sounded vastly different in the studio versions, but in concert, Hutson's copious use of harmonica gave many of them a rather authentic feel—Bridgers went full country.
«"Here's a country song for you," Bridgers said, introducing an unusually sincere and hopeful call to action about the desire to change for the better. It was certainly the most upbeat track of the evening, complete with acoustic guitar. (Personally, I especially loved the rhyme: "ocean" and "ibuprofen.")
Greetings from the past
Switching from guitar to Mellotron—where her mug rested between sips throughout the evening—Bridgers told the crowd she was going to play «a song about the past, which, as I’ve been told, is the meaning of every song.».
Needless to say, the lyrics were personal, frank, and brutally honest, considering that's arguably what Bridgers is known for as a songwriter. But this song was on a whole other level. (Let's just say it touches on a long-rumored engagement to an Irish ex-boyfriend, which she ultimately broke off.)
Turning on the light
As at countless concerts throughout history, there came a moment when the entire arena lit up with people waving flashlights in appreciation of a particularly touching song. But for the first time in perhaps a couple of decades, these were good old disposable lighters, not flashlights from phones still locked in their cases.
Bridgers was clearly captivated by the rare return to old rock 'n' roll traditions as she performed the fan favorite Punisher «"Graceland Too," she said, shaking her head in disbelief. "Unbelievable," she said quietly after the song ended.
Exclusive from MSG
Toward the end of her set, Bridgers performed the last of her unreleased songs, admitting she hadn't even performed it at any of the other shows on her acoustic tour. "If I screw this up, you won't tell anyone, right?" she said, standing behind the Mellotron, before launching into a sobering lyrical reflection on her position as a woman in time, reflecting, among other things, on the concept of motherhood.
Afterward, she dropped the bombshell. "We're going on tour," she said casually as the arena erupted in cheers, noting that she'd "really missed" performing on the road. (Presumably, she was referring to a larger tour in support of her next album, but that hasn't been confirmed yet.) "We'll tell everyone else tomorrow, but we'll tell you tonight.".
She added meaningfully: «I hope to see you this fall.».
Billboard's Best
-
Janet Jackson's Biggest Hits on the Billboard Hot 100
-
Chart Review: In 1996, Mariah Carey's "Baby" soared to number one on the Hot 100 chart.
-
Chart Review: In 1989, New Kids on the Block hit number one on the charts with "Hangin' Tough.".
Subscribe to the Billboard newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.