Director and screenwriter Michael Gallagher, another filmmaker who began his YouTube career with millions of subscribers thanks to shows like TotallySketch, Gallagher has always been slightly obsessed with the infamous 1997 mass suicide of the Heaven's Gate cult in Rancho Santa Fe, California, near where he grew up in San Diego. His interest in the horrific event and the cult that led to it intensified after his own paternal grandparents left the cult and founded a spiritual commune, and later after his cousin joined the cult from which she had to flee. The very idea of such cults, run by charismatic leaders who lure willing members into their ranks, even to their deaths, in search of spiritual guidance and redemption, is at the heart of Gallagher's new film. «"Leader", which just had its world premiere at the Tribeca Film Festival.
This is the story of a UFO cult known as "Heaven's Gate," which formed in the 1970s but ultimately led to the largest mass suicide in the United States in 1997. Led by Bonnie Lou Nettles (Vera Farmiga) and Marshall "Herff" Applewhite (Tim Blake Nelson), the cult, beginning in the 1970s, attracted dozens of people seeking spiritual awakening, which they were told would come when an alien spacecraft landed and whisked them away to nirvana—a life far more fulfilling than the one they were currently living.
More news from Deadline
-
Questlove and Earth, Wind & Fire rocked the opening night of Tribeca, and the founders reflected on their 25th anniversary: "Everything was going according to plan, and here we are.".
-
The 45 Most Anticipated Movies of 2026
-
Marc Maron and Rob Burnett discuss the existential tragicomedy "In Memoriam" at the Tribeca Film Festival, Maron's handling of the loss of co-star Lynn Shelton, and the "emptiness" left by the end of the "WTF" podcast.
In this widely acclaimed true story, Nettles, a nurse searching for meaning beyond traditional religions, becomes convinced she is chosen to lead others to a higher calling "beyond the stars." She meets Applewhite, an eccentric man with untreated mental illness and severe self-doubt, as they share a spiritual need and a kind of emotional connection. The result is the formation of their "organization," a blend of cosmic destiny and extreme Christianity, which attracts followers who need to belong. what whatever you like.
Over the years, the place evolves into what can best be described as a cult, similar to what Jim Jones managed to create outside of America. But Heaven's Gate has become something of a house built on sand, dependent on its founders to speak the truth and lead their flock to the promised afterlife. This includes true believer Warren (Jim Parsons), a stern man struggling with his own demons and temptations, who believes the necessary extreme structure and discipline will save him from himself. He is the most sincere of all the followers, more so than Michelle (the beautiful Grace Caroline Curry) and new recruit David (Simon Rex), who seem willing to obey until their mutual attraction and carnal perversions are exposed and they are forced to answer for their sins. It's such a place, but when Bonnie Lou gets sick (she died in 1985) and Herff is left to his own devices with his erratic behavior and erratic leadership, things start to go wrong.
Ultimately, all of this led to a mass suicide in 1997, not like Jones's cult in Guyana, where everyone drank a poisoned drink, but a more planned, individual transition to a promised life in the afterlife. A total of 39 bodies, including Applewhite's, were discovered in the rented mansion.
Gallagher lays it all out methodically and with a sense of complete authenticity, almost like a docudrama. This is the result of his extensive research, during which he pored over hours of recorded conversations with Applewhite and others to ensure the film was as faithful to the widely known real events as possible. He is greatly aided by Nelson's brilliant performance, who seems to have simply inhabited this deeply mentally ill man, also known as Do; and the determined but not crazy Nettles, aka Tee, played with incredible strength and confidence by the always convincing Farmiga, a role she seems born to play. Parsons is also superb as Rex, who suffers a sickening punishment for his misdeeds.
The film "The Leader"« , which is currently in the U.S., may not be the most enjoyable film to watch, but it's incredibly timely and relevant in a country and a world that currently seems full of lost people searching for some kind of connection not only with each other in a divided society, but also with themselves. Gallagher's film shows how easy it is to believe the big lie and the dire consequences it leads to for those who succumb to it.
Produced by Jana Gallagher, Michael Wormser, Joel David Moore, Matt Murphy and Michael Gallagher.
Name: Festival "Leader": Tribeca (film starring) Director-screenwriter: Michael Gallagher Starring: Tim Blake Nelson, Vera Farmiga, Jim Parsons, Grace Caroline Curry, Simon Rex Sales Agent: The Exchange/Voltage Duration: 1 hour 44 minutes
The Best of Deadline
-
The winners of the Grand Jury Prize in the Dramatic category at the Sundance Film Festival over the years.
-
Venice Film Festival Golden Lion Winners: Photos from all the festival's best films over the years.
-
Broadway's 2024-2025 Season: All the Deadline Reviews
Subscribe to the Deadline newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.